Randall McKenzie and Brandi Stewart-Sperry were found guilty of first-degree murder on April 24, 2025, for the shooting death of Ontario Provincial Police Constable Grzegorz “Greg” Pierzchala. The trial, held in Cayuga, Ontario, detailed the events of December 27, 2022, when Pierzchala was fatally shot during a police response on a rural road outside Hagersville. The prosecution presented compelling evidence, including body camera footage and text messages, linking the accused—who were out on bail at the time—to the fatal shooting and subsequent fleeing of the scene. The case has had a profound impact on the law enforcement community and local residents, highlighting the risks faced by officers in the line of duty.
Details of the Incident and Trial Proceedings
On December 27, 2022, Constable Grzegorz “Greg” Pierzchala was responding to a call on a rural road near Hagersville, Ontario, when he was fatally shot. The fatal encounter occurred during what was described as a routine police intervention that escalated tragically. The accused, Randall McKenzie and Brandi Stewart-Sperry, were both out on bail at the time. They were subsequently charged with first-degree murder in connection with the shooting.
During the trial held in Cayuga, Ontario, prosecutors introduced key pieces of evidence that formed the backbone of their case. Most notably, body camera footage captured during the incident provided clear visuals of the events as they unfolded, offering an unfiltered view of the encounter. Additionally, text messages exchanged between McKenzie and Stewart-Sperry suggested premeditation and an attempt to evade law enforcement following the shooting.
Prosecution’s Case and Evidence
The prosecution systematically laid out their arguments, emphasizing the deliberate nature of the shooting. The evidence suggested that the accused had knowingly taken part in the attack on Constable Pierzchala, contradicting defense claims of accidental involvement or misidentification. The timeline established through digital communications and witness testimonies helped to confirm the presence and actions of McKenzie and Stewart-Sperry at the scene.
Expert witnesses corroborated the forensic analysis of the shooting, linking ballistic evidence directly to the weapon associated with the defendants. The prosecution also highlighted the gravity of fleeing the scene, which compounded the severity of their actions and demonstrated consciousness of guilt.
Impact on the Community and Law Enforcement
The verdict has resonated deeply within the local community and among law enforcement officers across Ontario. Constable Pierzchala was remembered as a dedicated public servant whose death underscores the inherent dangers of police work, especially in rural areas where backup may take longer to arrive. Community leaders and police officials issued statements honoring his service and reaffirmed their commitment to ensuring the safety of officers on duty.
This case has also prompted discussions about bail conditions and monitoring, particularly for individuals previously charged with violent offenses. The killing has reignited calls for enhanced protective measures and review of protocols to better safeguard officers responding to emergencies.
Conclusion
The guilty verdicts against Randall McKenzie and Brandi Stewart-Sperry mark a significant legal resolution to the shooting of Constable Grzegorz Pierzchala. As the court proceeds to sentencing, the case remains a somber reminder of the risks law enforcement officers face daily. It also reinforces the judicial system’s role in addressing violence against public servants by ensuring accountability through the rule of law.
The guilty verdicts against Randall McKenzie and Brandi Stewart-Sperry bring closure to a tragic chapter marked by the loss of Constable Grzegorz Pierzchala. This case highlights the dangers inherent in police work and stresses the importance of stringent legal measures to hold offenders accountable. The outcome serves not only as a testament to the pursuit of justice but also as a catalyst for ongoing discussions on improving safety protocols for law enforcement personnel. As sentencing approaches, the community and law enforcement officials continue to honor Constable Pierzchala’s dedication and the sacrifice he made in the line of duty.
