The Special Investigations Unit (SIU) of Ontario has concluded its inquiry into the November 9, 2024, fatal shooting of 43-year-old Erixon Kabera by Hamilton police officers, determining that the officers acted with reasonable force under the circumstances. The SIU’s final report, released on June 6, 2025, found no evidence to support criminal charges against the officers involved, despite Kabera being armed only with a replica handgun at the time. The decision has elicited mixed reactions, with Kabera’s family expressing disappointment and contemplating legal action, while Hamilton Police emphasize their commitment to community dialogue and healing following the incident.
The Special Investigations Unit (SIU) launched an investigation immediately following the fatal shooting of Erixon Kabera on November 9, 2024. The incident occurred during a police response to reports of a man brandishing what was later identified as a replica firearm. Upon arrival, officers encountered Kabera, who was holding the replica handgun. According to the SIU report, the officers issued verbal commands before discharging their weapons when Kabera did not comply and appeared to pose an imminent threat to public safety.
SIU Investigation Findings
After a thorough review of body camera footage, witness statements, and forensic evidence, the SIU concluded that the Hamilton police officers employed force that was reasonable and necessary under the circumstances. The report highlighted several key factors that influenced this conclusion:
- Kabera’s failure to comply with police commands despite repeated warnings.
- The officers’ perception of an immediate danger due to the replica handgun resembling a real firearm.
- Standard police protocols that emphasize officer and public safety during armed encounters.
Based on these findings, the SIU determined that there was no reasonable basis to lay criminal charges against the officers involved.
Community and Family Reactions
Despite the SIU’s clearance of the officers, the decision has prompted a range of responses. Kabera’s family expressed sorrow and dissatisfaction with the report, citing concerns over the use of lethal force in a situation involving a non-lethal replica weapon. The family’s legal representatives have indicated plans to pursue further legal recourse to seek accountability and policy changes.
Conversely, Hamilton Police officials issued a statement reaffirming their dedication to fostering trust and open communication within the community. They acknowledged the emotional impact of the incident and committed to ongoing efforts aimed at community healing and transparency.
Context and Next Steps
This case adds to the broader discussion surrounding police use of force, particularly in encounters involving replica or non-lethal weapons. The incident underscores the challenges faced by law enforcement in rapidly assessing threats and making split-second decisions.
Hamilton Police have indicated that they will review their training and engagement protocols to potentially mitigate similar outcomes in the future. Meanwhile, the SIU has reiterated its role in providing independent oversight and maintaining public confidence in policing processes.
Observers and stakeholders continue to monitor developments as the community grapples with the implications of the incident and its aftermath.
The conclusion of the SIU investigation into the fatal shooting of Erixon Kabera affirms that the Hamilton police officers acted within the bounds of reasonable force given the circumstances. While the absence of criminal charges addresses legal accountability, the mixed reactions from Kabera’s family and the community highlight ongoing concerns about police interactions involving replica or non-lethal weapons. The case has prompted calls for continued dialogue, review of police protocols, and efforts to enhance community trust and safety. As this situation evolves, further legal actions and policy discussions are expected to shape the broader conversation on law enforcement practices and public safety in Hamilton and beyond.
