Ciro Garofano, an 81-year-old resident of Toronto, pleaded guilty on May 23, 2025, to second-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault in connection with a fatal hit-and-run incident that occurred on November 15, 2023. The case involves Garofano intentionally running over three family members outside an apartment in Scarborough, resulting in the death of Karen Montague and serious injuries to her husband and another relative. This plea follows charges originally including first-degree murder and attempted murder, reflecting the court’s acknowledgment of Garofano’s actions amid a motive linked to familial disputes over a late spouse’s will.
The tragic incident unfolded on the evening of November 15, 2023, outside an apartment building in the Scarborough area of Toronto. According to court records, Ciro Garofano deliberately used his vehicle to strike three members of the Montague family. Karen Montague, 58, succumbed to her injuries shortly after the collision, while her husband, David Montague, and another relative sustained severe injuries requiring extended medical treatment.
Prosecutors detailed that the attack was motivated by a long-standing dispute related to the inheritance of Garofano’s late spouse’s estate. The conflict reportedly escalated over time, culminating in this violent act. Initially, Garofano faced charges of first-degree murder and attempted murder, but these were amended following plea negotiations.
Plea Agreement and Court Proceedings
On May 23, 2025, Garofano entered a guilty plea to second-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault. The reduction from first-degree to second-degree murder acknowledges the absence of premeditation but confirms the intentional nature of the crime. This agreement was reached to avoid a lengthy trial and to provide some certainty of justice for the victims’ family.
During the sentencing hearing, Crown Attorney Lisa Bennet emphasized the calculated decision by Garofano to use his vehicle as a weapon, highlighting the preexisting familial tensions as a contributing factor. Defense counsel requested leniency due to Garofano’s advanced age and the impact of his actions on mental health.
Community and Family Reactions
The Montague family expressed relief that Garofano accepted responsibility but continued to mourn the loss of Karen Montague. Community leaders in Scarborough called for increased awareness and support for families dealing with inheritance disputes, underscoring the severe consequences such conflicts may entail.
Legal Implications and Future Proceedings
The case serves as a poignant example of the legal system addressing violent acts arising from personal disputes. Sentencing is scheduled for July 2025, where the presiding judge will consider factors including the defendant’s age, the nature of the crime, and its impact on victims and the community.
Authorities have reaffirmed their commitment to investigating and prosecuting similar incidents to ensure public safety and uphold justice.
The guilty plea entered by Ciro Garofano marks a significant development in this tragic case, underscoring the serious consequences of familial disputes escalating to violence. While the reduction to second-degree murder reflects the absence of premeditation, the court’s acknowledgement of the intentional nature of the act ensures accountability. The upcoming sentencing will consider multiple factors, including the defendant’s age and the profound impact on the victims and community. This case highlights the importance of addressing and mitigating conflict within families to prevent such devastating outcomes, while reinforcing the legal system’s role in delivering justice and supporting affected communities.